Deletion of second year representative requirement on the Committee
Proposed amendment
Article 7, Clause B, sub-clause 1 and 2 currently reads:
The Committee shall be composed of:
1. The Officers of the Society, namely the President, the Vice-President, the Secretary and the Treasurer
2. Five other committee members, one second year representative, and one first year representative (to be elected at the Society’s Initial General Meeting), or such number of other members as the Annual General Meeting may determine;
I propose amending sub-clause 2 so it reads as:
The Committee shall be composed of:
1. The Officers of the Society, namely the President, the Vice-President, the Secretary and the Treasurer
2. Five other committee members, and one first year representative (to be elected at the Society’s Initial General Meeting), or such number of other members as the Annual General Meeting may determine;
Effect of the amendment
If the amendment is passed then the Debating Society committee will not contain a mandated second year representative from 2010 onwards. Additionally, the committee will reduce in size by one person, ie the second year rep shall not be replaced. The committee will reduce from eleven to ten people.
Rationale for the change
It is difficult to see why the constitution mandates that there be a representative specifically for second years on the society’s committee. Unlike first year students, second year students are able to stand for election at the AGM each year. It is also hard to see that second year students have issues in debating that are separate to those of other students, or that those issues are incapable of being resolved without a dedicated representative.
I wish to stress that this proposed amendment should not be construed as an attack on anyone who has held the office of second year representative in the last few years.
In the event that the above is defeated (and only in that event) I also wish to move the following:
Amending sub-clause 2 so it reads as:
The Committee shall be composed of:
1. The Officers of the Society, namely the President, the Vice-President, the Secretary and the Treasurer
2. Five other committee members, and one first year representative (to be elected at the Society’s Initial General Meeting), or such number of other members as the Annual General Meeting may determine
Effect of the amendment
The effect of this amendment would be the same as above, except it would keep the same total number of committee members, ie the second year representative would be replaced by an additional general executive member.
Posted in AGM |